5/20/98 NIST Answers to the MINA question list of 4/26/98

Please send the webmaster [ e-mail to webmaster ] any new or follow up questions or comments about NIST's answers.
We intend to submit any new, clarification or follow up questions by June 5, 1998.

The questions below were sent to:
Dr. Subhas G. Malghan
Standards Conformity Program
Bldg. 820, Rm. 306
Gaithersburg, MD 20899
Tel. (301) 975-5120
Fax: (301) 975-5414
[ e-mail to malghan@nist.gov ]

April 26, 1998

 

Please answer the following questions on the FQA. If they are not within your area of responsibility then please pass them on to the appropriate person.

 

Key: questions are in bold type.

Affected sections or words are in bold italic type.

 

280.2 Definitions.

Who is a distributor?

<answer>This term is not defined in the Act or regs. A general definition would be a person who purchases for resale would be considered as a distributor.

 

How does an importer also qualify as a distributor?

<answer>Importer is defined in section 280.2 of the regs. An importer can become a distributor by reselling either imported or domestically purchased fasteners.

 

Who is a retail seller? ref 280.5 (b1A)

<answer>A good example would be Home Depot or an automobile dealer who sells to retail customers.

 

Who is a retail consumer? ref 280.5 (b1A)

<answer>A good example would be a person purchasing from the above mentioned sources.

 

 

ref 280.2

"Fastener" means any screw, nut, bolt or stud, washer or other item included within the definition for

fastener contained in section 3(5) of the Fastener Quality Act. The term "fastener" does not include

a screw, nut, bolt, or stud:

(3) that is held out as being produced to other than the provisions of standards and specifications

published by a consensus standards organization, or a government agency.

Does this mean only the USA federal government or does this include other state, national, or international governments?

<answer>Government here means U.S., State, local or foreign governments.

 

ref Section 3 (5) of the Fastener Quality Act and Section 3 (13) of the Fastener Quality Act

Section 3 (13) of the Fastener Quality Act

"standards and specifications" means the provisions of a document published by a consensus standards organization or a government agency;

What if that published standard has been cancelled or superceded or obsoleted?

<answer>If canceled, or obsolete it is not a standard any more. If superceded, a customers my(sic) order to either of the standards. The regs do not require that a purchaser should place orders only to the current version of standards.

 

If a national standard is no longer officially in effect, (such as dimensionally revised or superceded) then to what standard can a product be certified?

<answer>Customer decides to which standards a fastener is to be produced.

 

If no lab is certified to test a particular standard, then how can the product be FQA certified?

<answer>It is the responsibility of the manufacturer to find a lab to perform the required tests. It is as simple as a lab expanding the scope with the permission from their accreditation body.

 

What if you are manufacturing or altering a fastener to a standard and there are no qualified labs geographically close to your location and you would have to export the parts to another country for testing?

If the fasteners have to be exported for testing, then what arrangements have been made by NIST with US customs for this procedure of export and re-import? Example: duty drawback.

<answer>The U.S. Custom's has no specific responsibility under the FQA. The importer has a provision in the Act and regs to bring fasteners into the U.S. and get them tested and certified in an accredited lab. The Custom's will not hold shipment because an importer is intending to test fasteners in the U.S.

 

 

(5) "fastener" means-

(A) a-

(B) (i) screw, nut, bolt, or stud having internal or external threads, or

(ii) a load-indicating washer,

with a nominal diameter of 5 millimeters or greater, in the case of such items described in metric terms, or 1/4 inch or greater, in the case of

such items described in terms of the English system of measurement,

which contains any quantity of metal and is held out as meeting a

standard or specification which requires through-hardening,

 

If a 5 mm nominal diameter fastener is described as a 0.197 inches nominal diameter, is it then exempt from the act?

<answer>No, a 5-mm nominal diameter metric fastener is still a 5-mm fastener.

 

If a #12 nominal diameter fastener is described as 5.49 mm inches nominal diameter, is it then included in the act?

<answer>I am not sure what this question is about. I don't understand "5.49 mm inches."

(Editors note: This question was submitted with a typo. It should have read 5.49 mm, not 5.49 mm inches. We will re-submit the question, but the answer seems self-evident based on the prior question. NIST probably needs to clean up the language.)

 

Is what is primarily a dowel pin, but also has internal or external threads covered by the act?

<answer>Dowel pins are not covered by the FQA.

 

"Significantly Alter" means to alter in a manner which could weaken or otherwise materially affect the performance or capabilities of the fastener as it was originally manufactured, grade or property class marked, tested, or represented. The term does not include the application of adhesives or sealants, locking elements, provisions for lock wires, coatings and platings of parts having a specified Rockwell C hardness of less than 32, or cutting off of fasteners. The cutting of finished threaded rods, bars or studs to produce individual smaller length threaded studs for resale is not a significant alteration. However, cut threaded studs, rods, and bars offered for sale shall be

individually marked with the grade or property class identification marking appearing on or accompanying the original threaded studs, rods, and bars from which the fasteners were cut.

It is normal industry practice for this to be only a paint color, not a stamped marking.

Does this mean that each piece cut from a property class 8.8 threaded rod must also be paint marked?

What if paint marking is an objectionable feature to the end user?

What if the end user would like a different type of marking such as stamping?

<answer>The Act and regs require a significant alteror to follow the standards to which the alteration is done.

 

Certified Copy [of a laboratory testing report] means a complete and accurate copy of the original laboratory testing report, which contains a statement describing it as an accurate and complete copy of the original and which is signed by an authorized representative of the accredited laboratory issuing the report or, in the case of metal

chemistry testing reports, an authorized representative of the metal manufacturer.

May this report be photocopied?

Does the photocopy need an original signature?

<answer>Yes, if it is for a fastener manufacturer, the report can be copied and certified.

 

 

280.4 Commingling of Fasteners.ref Sec. 280.4 Commingling of Fasteners.

 

(a) No manufacturer, importer, or private label distributor may commingle fasteners of the same type, grade, and dimension from different lots in the same container; except that such manufacturer,

importer, or private label distributor may commingle fasteners of the same type, grade, and dimension from not more than two tested and certified lots in the same container during repackaging and plating operations: Provided, that any container which contains the fasteners from two lots shall be conspicuously marked with the lot identification numbers of both lots.

 

(b) Fastener distributors, and persons who purchase fasteners for sale at wholesale or retail, may commingle fasteners of the same type, grade, and dimension from different lots in the same container.

Does this mean that supplying an assortment in the same container, of covered fasteners is no longer permitted?

<answer>If you are distributor and your customer does not need lot specific fasteners, yes, the Act and regs allow you to commingle. Please note, imported fasteners do require lot traceability.

 

280.5 Certification of Fasteners.

ref Sec. 280.5 Certification of Fasteners.

 

(a) No fastener shall be offered for sale or sold in commerce unless it is part of a lot which has been inspected, tested, and certified in accordance with Section 5 of the Act and this part, and found to conform to the standards and specifications to which the manufacturer represents it has been manufactured.

Who exactly is entitled to a copy of this certification?

Distributors?

OEM's?

Retailers?

Consumers?

If OEM's, retailers or consumers are entitled, than how can this be possible after the parts may have been commingled per section 280.4 (b)?

See also 280.2 who is?

<answer>Anyone can request a copy of certification. If fasteners are commingled by the distributor, of course, that order can not be filled. If your question is related to your requirements as a distributor, pl(sic) see section 280.16.

 

(b) (1) the requirements of paragraph (a) of this section shall not apply to fasteners which are part of a lot of 50 fasteners or less if within 10 working days after delivery of such fasteners, or as soon as

practicable thereafter-

 

(i) inspection, testing, and certification as provided in subsections 5 (b), (c), and (d) of the Act and

this part is carried out; and

 

(ii) written notice detailing the results of such inspection, testing, and certification is sent:

 

(A) to all purchasers of such fasteners, except retail sellers and retail consumers; and

 

(B) to any retail seller or retail consumer who, prior to delivery, requests such written notice.

Does this mean that a retail consumer, for instance at a local hardware store or home center may request a copy of the certification papers?

<answer>Yes, but I don't know why they would do that.

 

280.11 Significant Alterations of Fasteners.

ref 280.11 (a)(3)

 

"unless the significantly altered fastener is delivered to a purchaser accompanied by a written statement noting the original lot number and the new lot number assigned by the alteror, disclosing the subsequent

alteration, and warning that such alteration may affect the dimensional or physical characteristics of the fastener."

Is the sample form below acceptable wording for NIST on the notification?

 

Supplying Company Name

Supplying Company Address

certifies that the fastener requested by:

Purchasing Company Name

Purchasing Company Address

on Date,

Purchase order number, _______________________________________________________

Purchase Order Line number or description, _____________________________________________________

Parts from Lot number, _________________________________________________________

Was/were manufactured, modified, altered or significantly altered to your specifications.

 

Pursuant to the Fastener Quality Act, section 280.11 (a) (3) Significant Alterations of Fasteners,

You are hereby given warning that such alteration may affect the dimensional or physical characteristics of the fastener.

 

<answer>The above statement as a declaimer looks fine.

. . . . . . . . . . .

 

 

 

What if the a fastener is sent to a machine shop for alteration, but the standard number of the original fastener is not known, for instance whether it was originally made to a DIN, ISO or UNI standard. In this situation, to what standard should the final product be tested to?

<answer>If the fastener is produced to FQA requirements, it should have the standards number.

 

If a machine shop is altering a fastener for a distributor and the fastener will need to be re-marked, whose head marking identification must be used; the machine shops or the distributors?

<answer>Of the one who owns the fastener at the time of alteration.

 

ref Section 280.11 Significant Alterations of Fasteners.

(b) If the significant alteration is only electroplating of fasteners having a specified Rockwell C hardness of 32 or above,

Property class 8.8 externally threaded fasteners have a Rockwell Hardness specification range of HRC 22-32 for nominal diameters less than 16 mm, and a hardness specification range of HRC 23-34 for nominal diameters 16 mm and greater. If upon specifying HRC values less than 32 for production, or by hardness testing the property class 8.8 fasteners are actually less than HRC 32, then are they exempt from the

significant alteration provision that requires a new lot number for electroplating?

<answer>If the minimum specified hardness is lower than Rc 32, then electroplating of such fasteners is not treated as a significant alteration.

 

or above, the requirements set forth in paragraphs (a)(2) and (a)(3) of this section

shall not apply, but the alteror shall assign a new lot number as set forth in paragraph (a)(1) and shall

test the electroplated fasteners as required by the plating standards and specifications.

Sec. 280.13 Imports of Fasteners.

 

(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b) of this section, it shall be unlawful for any person to sell to an importer,

How will BXA enforce this on an overseas supplier?

Has the USA State Department or other appropriate USA government agency notified all affected exporting governments that their nationals will be subject to and prosecuted under this law?

<answer>FQA is a U.S. law. It will be enforced in the U.S.

 

and for any importer to purchase any shipment of fasteners or fastener sets manufactured outside the United States unless such shipment to an importer is accompanied by a manufacturer's certificate of conformance, an original laboratory testing report with respect to each lot from which the fasteners are taken, and any other relevant lot identification information.

Does this mean that if we import a typical assortment box for example of 36 different property class 8.8 hex head cap screws and property class 8 hex nuts, that we would need 36 different sets of certification

papers along with 36 different lot numbers?

<answer>Each lot has to have certification.

 

 

(b) The requirement that delivery of fasteners to any importer must be accompanied by an original

laboratory testing report shall not apply:

 

(1) in the case of fasteners imported into the United States as products manufactured within a nation which is party to a congressionally approved free trade agreement with the United States that is in effect, provided that the Director has published in the Federal Register a certification that satisfactory arrangements have been reached by which purchasers within the United States can readily gain access to an original laboratory test report for such fasteners; or,

Why does NIST not intend to comply with the above provision? (Per Preamble)

<answer>No such arrangements exist at this time.

 

 

(2) in the case of fasteners imported into the United States as Canadian-origin products under the United States-Canada Automobile Pact for use as original equipment in the manufacture of motor vehicles.

 

What provisions have been made on how an importer or overseas supplier may advise US customs that certain imported fasteners were manufactured or modified before the effective date of the law?

Is this the suppliers or importers responsibility?

Is there an example of a format for this notification?

<answer>Though there is no requirement under the Act or regs, it will be a good practice for the imported fasteners to be marked clearly that they are FQA covered fasteners.

 

 

 

Sec. 280.700 Recorded insignia required prior to offer for sale.

 

(a) Any manufacturer or private label distributor of a fastener must, prior to any sale or offer for sale of any fastener which is required by the standards and specifications by which it is manufactured to bear a raised or depressed insignia identifying its manufacturer or private label distributor, apply for and record an insignia to be applied to any fastener which is to be sold or offered for sale to ensure that each fastener may be traced to its manufacturer or private label distributor.

Is it a correct assumption that a machine shop manufacturing or altering a fastener would be classified as a manufacturer?

<answer>Alteration as defined in the Act and regs can be conducted by a machine shop.

Other general operational questions:

If a sealed package of FQA certified product is sold to a customer, and then offered for return by that customer after the sealed package had been opened, can it be resealed and resold again as FQA certified product?

<answer>How do you know that the lot was not contaminated?

If several sealed packages of the same part number, but different lot number FQA certified products are damaged in shipment, and inadvertently co-mingled, must they all be scrapped?

In the above scenario, can the shipping company be charged back for the laboratory testing charges in addition to the charge for the replacement material?

<answer>It is entirely up to those involved in the transaction.

 

Must a fastener which was originally manufactured prior to the effective date of the FQA, but is significantly altered after the effective date be tested under the FQA?

<answer>No, it is not a FQA covered fastener.

 

Are pre-hardened bolt or nut blanks that were originally manufactured prior to the effective date of the FQA, but are trimmed to length and threaded after the effective date exempt from the FQA?

<answer>If the pre-hardened bolt was not covered by FQA because of production date being before the FQA implementation, future modifications to it are not going to make it a FQA-covered fastener.

 

If a manufacturer marked product undergoes a substantial alteration by an overseas machine shop before export to the USA, then what are the headmarking requirements?

<answer>If the original fastener standard required that headmarking be placed, then the altered fastener should meet the headmarking requirements.

 


CONTACTS AT: METRIC IMPORTERS OF NORTH AMERICA
[ e-mail to BONNIE CARTER c/o MINA ] [ e-mail to LEE SACKS c/o MINA ] [ e-mail to webmaster ]

[ Back to: METRIC IMPORTERS OF NORTH AMERICA home page ]

Please note that all Trademarks and Tradenames are the property of their respective owners.
copyright 1998 METRIC IMPORTERS OF NORTH AMERICA -- all rights reserved --
ver 236th date 5/23/98 fqa426.htm [Enhanced for Netscape/IE]
Thank you for visiting the MINA site.